RedLawList

Straightforward, actionable information for life’s common legal matters

Find an attorney at REDLAWLIST.ORG

Online Directory of Workers' Compensation, Personal Injury,
Consumer Protection and Criminal Defense Attorneys

  • Home
  • Knowledge Center
Home / Criminal Law / What Is Negligence? The 4 Key Elements You Must Prove In Court

What Is Negligence? The 4 Key Elements You Must Prove In Court

April 14, 2020 By RedLawList Editor

negligence

The principle of negligence underlies civil liability cases. We may have a general notion of what it is, but what is negligence in the strictest legal sense of the word? In reality, it’s an entire field of law unto itself that is undergirded by these 4 principles.

1. Duty

For someone to be legally negligent, they first have to be legally responsible for a situation. If you’re a homeowner, you may be legally required to have your sidewalk cleared of snow in a timely manner. If you have guests in your home, it’s considered understood that you have a legal obligation to make sure basic areas like the stairs are safe to go up and down.

If you’re a professional, opening for business creates an implied sense of duty. A doctor has a legal responsibility to their patients. A grocery store owner has a legal responsibility to keep the floors mopped and the aisles safe to walk through.

A lawsuit against a professional can also be called “malpractice,” which is a branch of negligence law.

2. Breach

Once the duty is established, you must prove that the defendant failed to meet their responsibility. That responsibility is to provide the standard of care consistent with community norms. Or, as the legal phrase goes, to do what “a reasonable and prudent person would do.”

This doctrine can potentially provide relief to plaintiffs. Let’s use the example of the person shoveling their sidewalk. Is it expected that this will be done by 7 a.m. after an overnight snowfall? There’s likely no law, so the courts have to fall back on what the reasonable person in this community does. In turn, that means if you’re out walking very early in the morning, the courts may well determine you had no right to assume the sidewalks would be safe.

On the professional level, particularly in areas like medicine, this is where expert witnesses come in. A surgeon being sued over an operation that went awry may call in colleagues from the area to testify that they followed the standard practice anyone else would have.

In short, the plaintiff has no responsibility to be perfect—but they must do what anyone else would reasonably do.

3. Causation

So you’ve established the defendant had a legal duty and failed to meet it. Now you must establish that this failure is the cause of your injuries. Maybe the sidewalk should have been shoveled and you slipped and fell. But did you have a bad hip to begin with? Now we’re in a gray area the courts must decide. In most states, they’ll also divide up responsibility. Courts may conclude that the defendant is only responsible for 60 percent of the injury and the damage award will be proportioned accordingly.

4. Damages

Finally, you need to prove that you were materially damaged by the defendant’s negligence. The easiest to prove is financial—through medical expenses, lost time at work, etc. The other aspect is emotional: did your injuries trigger depression? That’s more difficult to prove, but you can still seek to get compensation for your mental suffering.

Related resources

  • Frequently Asked Questions About Federal Crimes in Texas
    Frequently Asked Questions About Federal Crimes in Texas
  • Understanding the Differences Between Criminal and Civil Lawsuits
    Understanding the Differences Between Criminal and Civil…
  • A Primer on What to Do If You Are Sued
    A Primer on What to Do If You Are Sued

Filed Under: Criminal Law Tagged With: negligence

Legal Topics

  • Accidents & Injuries
  • Criminal Law
  • Defective Products
  • Insurance Disputes
  • Legal News
  • Workers' Compensation

Must Reads

  • Understanding the Alternatives to Foreclosure
  • What Can I Expect at a Mediation Session?
  • Why Having a Business Succession Plan is Important
  • 5 Legal Concerns for Owners of Waterfront Property

Blogroll

  • Attorney Web Marketing
  • The Babcock Law Firm
  • Lawteryx: The Legal T-Rex
  • Sid Gilreath Law Firm
  • Workers' Comp Lawyers: Gerber & Holder
  • American Bar Association
  • Cornell Legal Encyclopedia
  • The Crime Report
  • SCOTUS Blog
  • Volokn Conspiracy
  • Wall Street Journal Law Blog

Legal Directories

  • Enjuris: Directory for Personal Injury Lawyers
  • Martindale
  • RedLawList.org
  • Nolo
  • Find Law
  • Cornell Lawyer Directory

RSS Enjuris Law Blog

  • Top 5 Largest Dog Bite Verdicts and Settlements
  • What Is a Contingency Fee?
  • What Are the Potential Outcomes of a Personal Injury Lawsuit?
  • From Happy Meal to Heated Lawsuit: The McDonald's McNugget Case
  • Attorney Mike Redondo Discusses Liability in Florida Amusement Park Death

RSS Legal Week

  • New Colorado Law Extends Workers’ Comp Reporting Time July 27, 2022
  • Stephanie Tucker Receives WILG’s 2021 Rising Star Award November 13, 2021
  • Mack Babcock Swears In As President of WILG, A National Non-Profit for Injured Workers November 13, 2021
  • Differences in Workers’ Compensation Law July 27, 2021
  • Wall Street Journal Interviews Mack Babcock About COVID-19 Workers’ Comp Claims Denials April 9, 2021

RSS Lowering the Bar

  • Good Reason to Kill #78: Ate the Last Hot Pocket May 30, 2023
  • Bouncy-Castle King Gets 11 Years for Bouncy-Castle Arson May 22, 2023
  • Can You Claim a Reasonable Expectation of Privacy as a Guest If You Killed Your Hosts? May 12, 2023
  • Assorted Stupidity #155 April 28, 2023
  • Piano Man Convicted of Driving Piano While Under the Influence April 24, 2023

© 2023 RedLawList. All rights reserved.